This conversation reminds me of an interesting article I read in the latest Backcountry (Photo Annual) magazine by Biff America (pg 24). In it he begins to rant about a group on the uptrack in front of him who are carving the track up. He then makes these interesting observations:
"Now comes the tricky part. In my mind, those in the group in front of us were goofballs; clueless; whatever phrase works for you because they didn't respect the aesthetic beauty of a lone ski track up a beautiful valley. But the beauty of our sport - the reason we all love it - is that (other than keeping safe), there are no rules."
And isn't this one of the major drawcards for us all in the backcountry? The unfettered freedom to roam, the road less travelled, free of the encumbrances and rules that so dictate our normal lives?
He goes on to say:
"........ I can't just assume that everyone adheres to my values and/or follows my BC credos. I guess, in a nutshell, I'm foolish for letting a few extra skintracks cloud what was an otherwise magical morning."
and
"........ The biggest danger in getting older - other than death and wearing comfort waist jeans - is becoming the person you used to mock when you were young, that inflexible person who was adamant that their way was the only way."
The backcountry is about exploration and exhiliration. The moment we begin to impose rules and regulations, the magic begins to fade. I'm a firm believer in self determination, if you want to go out with no gear and no training, then be my guest. Just don't expect me to dig you out and you won't get any sympathy if you screw up and die or even worse, get severly injured. Just don't endanger me or my friends by your actions.
Don't expect me to invite you along, nor tolerate your company. Just go your own way.
In this day and age, there is more than enough readily accessible and relevant information and training regarding travel and safety in the backcountry. Ignore it at your own peril. There are no excuses.
My only concern with these individuals who for whatever reason choose to backcountry without the proper equipment or training is that they will get hurt or killed. Not if, just when. Past experience suggests that if enough of these incidents occur, we will go down the path of other countries, namely regulation and restriction. I would hate to see the government impose mandatory BC registration, licensing/permitting (ie. Rogers Pass) for all backcountry travel because a handfull of misinformed or ignorant rednecks stuff it up for the rest of us.
I can't really agree with 2wheeler with regard to those unable to afford equipment or training. This is a high risk activity where by your actions you can pose a significant danger to others. Think of those poor souls that have to come to their aid should they get caught in an avalanche and risk getting caught in a secondary slide?? There are ways to minimise cost (used gear etc), its all a matter of priorities.
To finish with, another quote from Biffs article:
"Sometimes you need to remind yourself to seize the day, live and let live, and remember that (other than being safe), there are no rules"